Signals from the Frontline #614: SoCal Open Recap and Ork Discussion

Join us for the live show on our Twitch channel by following this link! The show starts at 11am, PST. The podcast and YouTube video-cast air at 9am, PST every Friday.

Show Notes

Date: 10-31-18

Intro

  • Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Twitch, and YouTube!  Join our Forums, too! If you would like to be a guest on the show, email Reece at Contact@FrontlineGaming.org
  • We sell tabletop games and supplies at a discount! Hit us up for your next gaming order at Orders@FrontlineGaming.org or visit our webstore at store.FrontlineGaming.org.

News

  • We’ve got a brand new FLG Mat available for you, Battlefield! It is available at a 20% discount through November 13th, 2018.

  • The SoCal Open has come and gone and it was great! We had a great turnout and a ton of fun!

  • 40k saw some awesome action and Brandon Grant took it again this year with his Castellan+IG army, and Cooper Waddell took second, going undefeated with Nids/GSC and taking Renaissance Man. Alex Aquila got third, technically also going undefeated  Andy Trimlett took best appearance with his Orks.
    • In the top 10 we had:

  • PJ Pants won the AoS event with Flesh Eater Courts, Kurt Roper took second with Daughters of Khaine, and third was a three way tie between Alex Gonzalez with Nighthaunts, Greg Goade’s Daughters of Khaine, and Matthew Pashby’s Idoneth Deepkin.

 

Upcoming ITC Events

Upcoming 40k ITC Events

Upcoming AoS ITC Events

40k ITC Top 10

Click here for full rankings.

Rank First Name Last Name Points Events
1 Nick Nanavati 755.16 5 of 5
2 Mike Porter 744.54 5 of 5
3 Matt Root 694.28 5 of 5
4 Trent Northington 692.04 5 of 5
5 Joshua Death 651.29 5 of 5
6 Archon Skari 650.81 5 of 5
7 John Lennon 627.22 5 of 5
8 Leigh Abbey 626.46 5 of 5
9 Andrew Gonyo 625.42 5 of 5
10 Nick Rose 620.54 5 of 5

40k ITC Hobby Track Top 10

Click here for full rankings.

Rank First Name Last Name Points Events
1 Matthew Bodnarchuk 476.65 5 of 5
2 Lou Rollins 422.14 4 of 5
3 Mike Genoni 403.04 4 of 5
4 David Danuser 381.96 5 of 5
5 Antonio Cedeno 357.1 5 of 5
6 Jeffrey Merrick 348.7 4 of 5
7 Shawn Prosser 332.62 5 of 5
8 Nick Gower 327.37 4 of 5
9 Eric Dionne 309.01 3 of 5
10 Cheryl Matthynssens 297.89 4 of 5

AoS ITC Top 10

Click here for full rankings.

Rank First Name Last Name Points Events
1 Joe Krier 531.97 5 of 5
2 James Thomas 446.05 4 of 5
3 Matthew Pashby 439.81 4 of 5
4 Mathew Jones 439.17 4 of 5
5 Joshua Harvey 427.39 4 of 5
6 Steven Hyche 419.67 4 of 5
7 Ken Eubanks 417.31 4 of 5
8 Alex Gonzalez 415.73 4 of 5
9 James Tapia 406.67 4 of 5
10 Jarrett Zazuetta 401.56 4 of 5

AoS ITC Hobby Track Top 10

Click here for full rankings.

Rank First Name Last Name Points Events
1 Sid Singh 298.4 3 of 5
2 Philip Verduzco 270.45 3 of 5
3 Josh Lara 260.24 3 of 5
4 Ben Nelson 239.3 3 of 5
5 Joseph Halfacre 173.36 2 of 5
6 Jon Christenson 161.9 2 of 5
7 Frank DeLoach 158.62 2 of 5
8 Scott Reed 155.07 2 of 5
9 Joshua Harvey 150.5 2 of 5
10 Josh Greenfield 124.35 2 of 5

Shadespire ITC Top 10

Click here for full rankings.

Rank First Name Last Name Points Events
1 Mike Corse 333.98 3 of 5
2 Andrew Everhart 333.63 3 of 5
3 Brandon Ulick 331.53 3 of 5
4 Matt Everhart 330.9 3 of 5
5 Tony Field 329.89 3 of 5
6 Michael Rundles 329.17 3 of 5
7 Britt Davis 317.72 3 of 5
8 Mike Melody 303.66 3 of 5
9 Adam Brazzell 299.67 3 of 5
10 Josue Ibarra 299.46 3 of 5

Tactics Corner

Completed Commissions

  • Check out some of this beautiful commissions recently completed by the FLG Paint Studio!

And remember, Frontline Gaming sells gaming products at a discount, every day in their webcart!

secondhandhsop

Tags:

About Reecius

The fearless leader of the intrepid group of gamers gone retailers at Frontline Gaming!
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
36 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Embrace Your Inner Geek
Embrace Your Inner Geek
3 years ago

Hey guys – who do I contact about updates to the ITC rankings. There’s an event that’s submitted but not updated yet. Want to make sure that it’s not missing any information.

Embrace Your Inner Geek
Embrace Your Inner Geek
3 years ago
Reply to  Reecius

Thanks Reece – email sent

rvd1ofakind
rvd1ofakind
3 years ago

The painboy works on Grots though. Infantry, which grots have.

I think it’s crazy that people are thinking of ditching them. Tide of traitors, biggest blob for the +1 attack buffs, morale immunity for nearby orks as long as you have a big blob, can dajump and charge 8” with full re-rolls, troops to fill batallions and get obsec. They can now also take 3 free tanbusta bombs, they get other clan traits, stratagems, etc. I think they got way more than +1 pts.

rvd1ofakind
rvd1ofakind
3 years ago
Reply to  rvd1ofakind

Second paragraph is about Boyz ofc

abusepuppy
3 years ago
Reply to  rvd1ofakind

Yeah, Boyz are still insanely good, even at 7pts.

abusepuppy
3 years ago

Seems a bit premature to be calling the Knights meta dead when a very standard Castellan list took 1st place at the event. Knights are very much still alive and well, although with the coming of Orks that may not be true for very much longer; still, for the time being they are a force to be reckoned with.

What the Sisters codex will do remains to be seen, but I don’t think it’s gonna be a hard counter to Orks in any particular fashion. Sisters are a shooting army, and a relatively short-ranged one at that; Orks are not particularly scared of anything that needs to be within 12″ of them to do its work.

Zweischneid
Zweischneid
3 years ago

“Hey.. Ynnari are too good. Whish they were changed completely. Extra-activations just break the game.”

2 minutes later

“Look, now Ork codex double-moving, double-shooting, double-fighting awesomeness all around!!!”

Lol.

Zweischneid
Zweischneid
3 years ago
Reply to  Reecius

Not doubting Ynnari aren’t good, but they do give up a lot for it.

If Dark Reapers just double shoot for 2CP like Hive Guard (Obliterators, now Orks, whatever, etc..), Yvraine would just hand out double-moves like Swarm Lord and Shining Spears would double-fight and/or double move like Genestealers, but in return they don’t lose Craftworld traits (e.g. perhaps saving CP in turn by having -1 built in, rather than lighting-reflexes, etc.), Battle Focus, etc.. could still take different warlord traits, not have as many points-of-failure with psychic powers (deny, etc..) just doing it far more reliably (if perhaps less often) with stratagems, it’d be mostly a wash.

And other armies save resources too. Ion Bulwark is effectively 18 CP “saved” on a Castellan in a 6 round game (not even counting the utility of playing Rotate Ion Shields on top of it or on another knight).

That’s a lot of double activations Ynnari have to pull off successfully to draw even, not even counting the additional resources in psykers, lost chapter traits, etc.. they need to invest to play.

Zweischneid
Zweischneid
3 years ago
Reply to  Reecius

Yes. Not saying they don’t need adjusting.

Just saying what makes them strong isn’t unique to them.

Double activations of all kinds are frequent in all armies, and a rather poor game-design choice in all cases.

– They allow players to spike the efficiency of their most effective and efficient armies.
– They allow players to double-dip into buffs/debuffs, be it Precience/VotLW, Guide/Doom, Red Rampage/Might of Heroes, or whatever, in ways the resource cost of those powers don’t account for.
– They reduce further reduce the interactivity/reaction ability of players, which is already limited in a 5-6 turn game of IGO-UGO.

Whether it’s Ynnari, in-built stuff like Swarmlord or double-shooting Leman Russes, Stratagems, etc.., I think they are a large factor in the rather one-sided arms race 40K has seen over the last year in the transition from Index to Codex, where the offensive side of things, for the most part, has far outpaced the defensive side of things (with too few exceptions like -1 to hit armies or insane invuls. like Prophets of Flesh or Knights).

Ynnari highlight the problem most notably, but it’s a systemic problem in game design of introducing double activations that IMO goes beyond Ynnari and will pop up as a problem, even if Ynnari get nerfed out of the most immediate spotlight.

Zweischneid
Zweischneid
3 years ago
Reply to  Reecius

yes and no.

In my personal humble opinion, I think Codexes have been stacking it too much on the offensive side.

– Units like Russes, Fire Prisms and now Battlewagon variants shooting twice, but no units taking half the hits if they move less.

– Lots of +1 to hit or wound like VoTW, the Tau strat, now Moster Hunters, but not nearly enough -1 to balance it out.

– Lots of double-fighting, double shooting, double-moving strats, but not a single -1 activation strat to balance it in the game (except Vect, I suppose).

Obviously not everything needs an exact mirror, but the offensive vs. defensive capacities of armies has definitely shifted strongly towards the former since index-8th edition, and it’s inevitably creating an ever more “glasshammer 40K” dominated by blow-outs and a few extreme defense-concept armies.

Zweischneid
Zweischneid
3 years ago
Reply to  Reecius

I disagree.

Just upping the offensive side of things doesn’t balance things, IMO.

It just aggravates the problem of who get’s the first turn to squeeze in all those multiple activations of killyness.

It also reduces the interactivity in a 5-6 turn IGO-UGO format, where there are only 5 or so turns to “react” anyhow.

It’s a premier reason stuff like power armour feels increasingly redundant. Upping their offensive output only goes so far, unless they are .. at the extreme end of the trend, pointed equally to guardsman because the defensive side is next-to-useless.

Sure, 8th made the conscious decision to be more lethal than 7th, already at the index. Maybe designers thought it wasn’t lethal enough in index-8th, which is why they upped the lethality again, without defence keeping pace.

But a), the trend is unsustainable in the long run, obvious, and b) is a major factor why only “extreme defensive concepts” like super-hordes or super-defensive denial style lists, whether it’s stacking -1s or T8 4++ or even 3++ all around are the only things still cutting it.

The “battle-report” style Marine or Necron armies or whatever have clearly been out-inflated by the (mainly damage-side) codex creep.

rvd1ofakind
rvd1ofakind
3 years ago

Oh god. 15 lootas mobbed up with 10 lootas, re-rolling 1s, more dakka, double shoot. OH GOD.

rvd1ofakind
rvd1ofakind
3 years ago
Reply to  Reecius

Well they can hide behind LoS and move out (more dakka cancels -1 to hit for moving). So they’ll shoot first most of the time and then you have to kill 60+ 5++ 6+++ gretchin to get to them lol (in my world I make all the 2+ to pass wound off to gretchin :p). Plus range 48”

rvd1ofakind
rvd1ofakind
3 years ago

Alright. Does Painboy and Grotshield stack? Like if you take a wound on Lootas, you go 6+++, then 2+ to pass it to the grot. Big FAQ prevents double feel no pain unit abilities. However the grot thing is not really FNP but more of a “look out sir”(it’s relevant because the 3 examples given are all FNPs) and ofc it isn’t a unit ability, it’s a stratagem.

Dakkath
Dakkath
3 years ago
Reply to  rvd1ofakind

I *think* the way it works is you try to pass wounds off, then save.

abusepuppy
3 years ago
Reply to  rvd1ofakind

It depends on whose turn it is. When multiple effects would trigger at the same time, the player whose turn it is gets to decide which order the apply in- so your enemy can force you to to take your Painboy save first and then pass along to Grots, or make you do the Grots first and then get your Painboy save, depending on which they think is more advantageous. (Typically, they will want to do the latter.)

But both abilities are applicable, as they are different kinds of rolls and can thus be stacked even with the new FAQs.

AJShadowhawk
AJShadowhawk
3 years ago

Is it possible to get Lou’s Deathwatch army list?

AJShadowhawk
AJShadowhawk
3 years ago
Reply to  Reecius

I know it’s not much of an excuse, but I live in Dubai and will be moving back to India very soon, so have not gotten a subscription because of that.

Marius Xerxes
Marius Xerxes
3 years ago
Reply to  AJShadowhawk

Most of the lists are posted in various threads on Dakka already.

AllHail
AllHail
3 years ago

These 4 wall special LOS blocking buildings I’m hearing about, did players have any warning before the event that that kind of “terrain” was going to be used? Seems to heavily favor infantry and especially infantry with mortars.

AllHail
AllHail
3 years ago
Reply to  AllHail

I thought the actual ruins models had windows/slits that provided LOS, but there were special rules in effect that say no LOS for the first floor of the ruins. Most ruins have gaps/windows don’t they?

I can’t tell from the pictures if the windows are painted on or actual holes in the building.

AllHail
AllHail
3 years ago

Nice to know about the ruins, on an unrelated note I see in one of these pictures there are Eldar flyers with their bases sideways. Isn’t that a type of modeling for advantage? You can move forward and block more ground movement with the bases sideways like that….

Marius Xerxes
Marius Xerxes
3 years ago
Reply to  AllHail

You could just turn the flier sideways if you wanted anyway. All weapons shoot 360 degrees in this edition so no advantage there.

Plus, CWE Fliers get to turn 90 degrees before and after their move so its not much of a mobility benefit either.

My guess is that people just like the look of the base like that or are used to seeing it that way from other large (Knights) models anyway.

AllHail
AllHail
3 years ago
Reply to  Marius Xerxes

I forgot they could turn 90 degrees again after the move with their special ability, I guess it doesn’t matter much then.

36
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x