Signals from the Frontline #472: Genestealer Cults, OP?

Join us for the LIVE show at 11am PST on our Twitch Channel!

Show Notes

Date: 10-7-16

Intro

  • Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Twitch, and YouTube!  Join our Forums, too! If you would like to be a guest on the show, email Reece at Contact@FrontlineGaming.org
  • We sell tabletop games and supplies at 20% off! Hit us up for your next gaming order at Orders@FrontlineGaming.org or visit our webstore at FrontlineGaming.org.
  • You think Reecius’ T-Shirts are cool? Buy yours, here!

News

  • Raging Heroes unleashed some awaited mech giants:
    • The 3 TGG Mechas (KST, JB and IE)
    • Are you ready for some scifi mechanic madness? Raging Heroes are finally releasing the TGG Mechas from their first Kickstarter, The Toughest Girls Of The Galaxy.
    • Each Mecha is posable with the ball-joint system, so you can tweak them as you want and make awesome dynamic poses. Also, each one comes with 1 pilot + 3 heads options, and of course one50mm round base.
    • The 3 TGG Mechas are now available, one for each TGG faction: Jailbirds, Iron Empire and KST. It’s time to upgrade your army to the next level of awesomeness: 

jailbirds-mecha-v2 jbmechaclosbadass kst-mecha mechaie

itcterraincargo5ITC squarebuilding1

  • Games Workshop is hiring someone for their social media team! Send in your application if interested.
  • The Las Vegas Open continues to break attendance records! We’ve got new events on the way too, including an Ork Train battle casual 40k event, Beer Hammer is coming back, Mantic Games, and more! We’ve also got cool LVO apparel in the webcart to grab! You will pick them up at registration.
  • Be sure to check out the latest 40k narrative video bat rep! The team has really upped their game and these look fantastic.

  • New Black Library Novels on the way!
Sons of the Forge

Sons of the Forge

Magnus the Red

Magnus the Red

Blood Bowl novels

Blood Bowl novels

Fabius Bile

Fabius Bile

  • Make sure to take advantage of the Genestealer Cults sale we’ve got going on!

fb-genestealer-ad

  • And, we’ve got two new F.A.T. Mats available for your games!

aa73c2ba15d8b45364378331826ce461188ef92756ce98f17dpimgpsh_fullsize_distr

Upcoming ITC Events

itc.logo.01.1

Full rankings, here.

ITC Championship Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Matt Root FNGC 11 748.73
2 Brandon Grant PE 8 645.07
3 Joshua Death N/A 15 644.06
4 Aaron Aleong nWo 5 630.25
5 Thomas Hegstrom Oakey 2DR’s 11 623.28
6 Brett Perkins FMs 7 621.48
7 Dan Platt CanHam 8 615.76
8 Andrew Gonyo BCoast 9 607.84
9 James Carmona TZC 9 599.5
10 Matthew Schuchman BCoast 9 583.35

ITC Team Rankings

Rank Club Name Club Code Placings Points
1 Beast Coast BCoast 113 1346.92
2 nWo Blackshirts nWo 84 1306.84
3 Team Zero Comp TZC 80 1294.38

Adepta Sororitas

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Bartosz Czolczynski short 11 396.18
2 Nick Barden short 6 308.29
3 Joshua Shubert HT 6 297.38

Adeptus Astartes

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Thomas Hegstrom Oakey 2DR’s 10 509.4
2 Justin Pizzoferrato Merc40k 5 459.14
3 Adam Napier TfDU 4 436.21

Astra Militarum

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Wesley Pauley short 5 384.9
2 Carlos Kaiser REKT 6 384.05
3 Sean Porter short 4 325.24

Blood Angels

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Chris Morgan short 5 304.26
2 Iain McLeod GWNG 4 273.22
3 Danny Kwan REKT 7 253.56

Chaos Daemons

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Trent Northington Warhogs 6 479.05
2 Eric Hoerger BCoast 4 475.89
3 James Carmona TZC 7 460.95

Chaos Renegades

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Brett Perkins FMs 6 507.95
2 Lukash Nahachewsky nWo 5 435.94
3 Adam Solis REKT 9 347.45

Chaos Space Marines

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Alan Dehesa RQTF 6 378.9
2 Chuck Arnett Mugu 6 367.72
3 Todd Silber DSD 3 283.46

Cult Mechanicus

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Matt Root FNGC 6 620.2
2 Geoff Robinson TZC 7 470.35
3 Aaron Towler Chicago2 5 395.24

Dark Angels

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Brandon Grant PE 7 542.48
2 Aaron Aleong nWo 5 534.87
3 Rafał Kroczka 3citys 7 418.64

Dark Eldar

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Willow Ryder LCC 4 331.66
2 Jeff Biery CofC 3 301.01
3 Michael McGuiggan GaGate 4 300.48

Deathwatch

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Matthew Stephens Deff 2 197.29
2 David Johansen 2DR’s 1 111.44
3 Dan Biela N/A 1 89.97

Eldar

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Brad Chester N/A 4 481.71
2 Matthew Schuchman BCoast 9 477.93
3 Chris Hanes CanHam 5 464.43

Eldar Corsairs

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Carter Leach N/A 8 420.43
2 Jeff Biery CofC 3 327.17
3 Herb Shaffer Herbs 4 311.48

Genestealer Cult Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Lee Hartsoe short 2 113.25
2 Jessup Coffin N/A 1 107.87
3 Jonathan Camacho Sex 1 97.84

Grey Knights Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Chris Aynesworth WSOS 3 260.03
2 Dj Timms N/A 3 259.1
3 Dan Comeau Warhogs 5 252.07

Harlequins

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Robert Dayton MH 4 194.91
2 Joshua Death N/A 2 179.34
3 Garrett Lilley Bako 4 150.43

Imperial Knights

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Adrian James HerbAs 7 420.42
2 Joshua Death N/A 6 391.1
3 Mike Keys short 9 371.09

Inquisition

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Wesley Pauley short 4 351.34
2 Randolph Soanes-ulrich GWNG 7 283.06
3 Adam Devitt PhGames 3 213.74

Knights Renegades Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 John Eubanks short 4 407.56
2 Alex Gonzalez LCC 3 292.62
3 Aaron Hayden PE 3 268.38

Khorne Daemonnkin

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Horton Doughton Border 5 405.12
2 Mark Perry SMG 7 371.7
3 Brad Bitler DSD 5 346.74

Militarum Tempestus

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Mycroft Holmes N/A 2 179.57
2 David Koszka B&W 2 136.92
3 Josef McCoy Deff 2 116.52

Necrons Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Alexander Fennell DSD 7 452.29
2 Alex Gonzalez LCC 8 436.38
3 Baxter Seguin Mugu 8 403.92

Officio Assassinorum Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Josh Bagwell Mugu 4 269.63
2 Justin Mananna Cox BCoast 4 228.09
3 Mike”Juice Springsten” Vagenos PowTH 2 149.1

Orks Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Rich Kilton 2DR’s 8 415.76
2 Troy Graber FMs 10 402.39
3 Jacob Ballard DefHaw 7 370.76

Skitarii

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Quinn Shepas short 6 381.81
2 Matt Evans Flipside 2 129.41
3 Phil Harlos GWNG 1 118.07

Space Wolves Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Mike Kriegler nWo 7 480.2
2 Trevor Sandoval RQTF 6 454.84
3 Logan Shelton short 8 420.19

Tau Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Andrew Gonyo BCoast 8 495.7
2 Jeremy Veysseire TZC 6 447.82
3 Kenneth Johnson WMs 8 443.67

Tyranids Rankings

Rank First Name Last Name Club Events Points
1 Tyler Larson Mugu 9 354.28
2 Jaminh Vo MH 6 306.6
3 Matt Evans Flipside 4 302.39

Rumors: The Rumor Section is gathered from the web and is not in any way information we receive from  any manufacturer nor is it necessarily accurate. This section of the podcast is intended for entertainment purposes only.

  • Space Marines: Strike Force Ultima:
    • Captain
    • Sternguard
    • Termies
    • Tac Squad
    • Stormhawk
    • Land Raider
    • Drop Pod
    • All units must start in reseve, automatically arrive turn 1. Add 1 to all shots for models in this formaiton the turn they arrive….wow.

Rant Session

Tactics Corner

  • Genestealer Cults chatter: are they TOO good?

Rules Lawyer

Completed Commissions

List Review

Tags:

About Reecius

The fearless leader of the intrepid group of gamers gone retailers at Frontline Gaming!

35 Responses to “Signals from the Frontline #472: Genestealer Cults, OP?”

  1. Avatar
    AngryPanda October 7, 2016 10:40 am #

    Excuse me I need to go find me a badger like right now!

  2. Avatar
    Nalathani October 7, 2016 11:17 am #

    I’m at work, so I can’t join the Twitch chat, so I’m going to comment here.

    Anyone who is a regular over at TheTyranidHive forums knows that we’ve been analyzing this codex to death ever since the leaks started up. It’s a very, very good codex. No doubt about that. I do think that calling it OP is a bit alarmist.

    The meta at this point is all about cramming as many heavy guns and nearly invincible units on the table. It’s all about the Grav, Meltas, Gargantuan Creatures, Superheavies, and Deathstars. When no one bubble-wraps their heavies with infantry, and they get charged, of course they’re going to scream OP! When no one takes flamers, large blasts, or massed rapid fire weapons (bolters!) it’s going to seem like there’s just too much to kill in a well designed horde army.

    I bet you in a few months the meta will start to change. You’re going to see a few more cheap troops on the table to absorb charges. You’re going to see just a few more flamers and large blasts to thin out those blobs of Purestrains and Acolytes. When it all settles I think this codex will be one of the best things to hit the game. An army with no Superheavies, no GC’s, no deathstars. Just lots of infantry for people to shoot at, and worry about positioning for assaults.

    • Reecius
      Reecius October 7, 2016 12:30 pm #

      I agree on all points and that is why there is a question mark in the title. We’re asking, not stating =)

  3. Avatar
    Alex R October 7, 2016 12:57 pm #

    OP no change in play style yes. Will it be able to compete with eldar is what im curioud about. Space marines shouldnt have to much of a problem with most army builds. Got to love the old rhino

    • Reecius
      Reecius October 7, 2016 1:23 pm #

      I think Eldar will live in fear of Genestealer Cults. They have the right tools.

      • Avatar
        Blight October 7, 2016 1:52 pm #

        Would love to see an Eldar spoiler army.
        My local group’s eldar player says he isn’t worried and that genecult looks terrible but I think he’s massively underestimating them.

        • Reecius
          Reecius October 7, 2016 2:25 pm #

          I feel like they have all of the tools to take Eldar out, personally.

          • Avatar
            C-Stock October 7, 2016 3:53 pm
            #

            I feel like they have all the tools to take out all armies. Popup-assault buckets of S4 rending death on absurdly high initiative kills virtually everything in 40k that’s not an upper-tier invisible death star.

      • Avatar
        AbusePuppy October 8, 2016 12:27 am #

        Mmm. Eldar don’t like reserve armies, it’s true, and assaults are one of the better ways to do damage to a lot of their stuff, but many Eldar armies run Tau alongside to stop reserve shenanigans, and Tau put an end to most GSC stuff toot suite.

        I don’t think it’s going to fundamentally change anything for Eldar. It will be an army that is a less-favorable matchup for them, but those already exist- the problem is that those armies struggle to reach the top tables where Eldar typically live at. GSC are not going to challenge a lot of the other armies out there very much- not Battle Company (who has the Bolters and melee attacks as well as Flamer options to kill them pretty easily), not Tau (who will destroy them before they really even get a turn), not any of the various deathstars (since GSC rely heavily on melee to do their work, which is where deathstars shine) and not the various Daemonic lists (who, again, live primarily in melee and should easily be able to beat them in combat and then sweep them.)

      • Avatar
        Hiveminded October 10, 2016 4:36 pm #

        GSC are a hard counter to certain staples in the current meta like jetbikes and warp spiders.

        That doesn’t make them OP. It makes them good for the game.

  4. Avatar
    C-Stock October 7, 2016 3:48 pm #

    The issue isn’t that eldar would be foiled, it’s that all the codexes that are lesser than Eldar are also foiled at least as much.

    And bubble wrap is of limited use against an army exceptionally well equipped to take out the bubble wrap in record time, or just pinpoint no scatter deep strike around the wrap. Metamorphs get what 4 attacks each on the charge? Plus more shenanigans to make that even better?

    And how are the fast armies supposed to play with bubble wrap? Are dark eldar supposed to bubble wrap and castle in the corner with their skimmers? Cede all the objectives to the GSC army and just try to stay alive? It just doesn’t make sense.

    Poor blood angels, they just got a new codex and already they just look like victims.

    • Reecius
      Reecius October 7, 2016 3:56 pm #

      I really think you guys are overreacting. I could be wrong of course but these are T3 models with a 5+, lol. Overwatch alone will hurt them badly.

      Let’s say you have 12 units, only 3-4 of them will actually get to charge. If they’re 5 man (which they’d have to be), that really isn’t that many attacks. Yeah, they hit hard, yeah, they’re good but I don’t see them dominating the meta or anything. Time will tell, I have yet to play them, but they are paper thin.

      • Avatar
        AngryPanda October 7, 2016 4:00 pm #

        They are great against Eldar and the cult ambush seems to get mistaken for a definite charge in some people’s heads.
        So that may cause it. I think the Dark Angels Gladius just laughs at any attempt of these guys charging them.
        And as a Necron player I just shrugs and say bring it. I can take as hard as you can dish out but you can’t take what comes back.
        I still think the super mobile scoring is the best part and that is probably super hard to deal with.

        • Avatar
          Blight October 7, 2016 7:04 pm #

          I do feel like people focus too much on the charge from reserves on a 6 stuff. Their ability to appear on objectives is what will win them the game.

  5. Avatar
    Hiveminded October 7, 2016 7:05 pm #

    The notion that GSC is OP is laughable. It’s not even going to be a top tier codex. There is a lot of chicken little “the sky is falling” going on out there. And what’s worse, a lot of the people complaining about the GSC codex have not even played against the army. Many people are forming strong opinions and being very vocal based purely on some mathhammering.

    It’s an army of 5+ save models…

    Before anyone comments about how OP GSC is, please post how many games you’ve played against them :). The codex has been out a week. My guess is that most people complaining haven’t even seen them in the table yet.

    • Reecius
      Reecius October 8, 2016 7:42 pm #

      I am in agreement with you. I was very surprised to get the emails about them dominating early tournaments, frankly.

  6. Avatar
    C-Stock October 7, 2016 8:50 pm #

    Don’t these guys get shrouded the turn they come in? When they have a 2+ or 3+ save, how are they going to dis easy to shooting even at T3?

    • Avatar
      AbusePuppy October 8, 2016 12:29 am #

      If they naturally had Infiltrate (which some but not all of the units do), they get Shrouded as part of the Ambush. And it’s only for the first turn of the game, I believe.

      • Reecius
        Reecius October 8, 2016 7:41 pm #

        Yeah, only turn 1 unless I am missing something. Really not that crazy.

        • Avatar
          Jural October 10, 2016 8:56 am #

          And now we may begin to see why they are so OP… people don’t read the rules! And for the first few tournaments, people may be able to get away with “liberal” interpretations of the dex. (I always can charge from reserve, my Decurion gives me shrouded…)

    • Avatar
      Hiveminded October 8, 2016 8:20 pm #

      It’s only for turn 1, and it’s only if you take a specific formation, and even then, it’s only applicable to those models who normally have the infiltrate rule in their unit entry (i.e. purestrain genestealers and the HQs).

  7. Avatar
    AngryPanda October 7, 2016 11:30 pm #

    I feel like we are all losing focus on the real major story here. Which is that some dude actualy sat down and wrote FOUR books about someone playing Bloodbowl. That is amazing and wrong on so many levels.

  8. Avatar
    Colin Sherlow October 8, 2016 5:21 am #

    I wonder if you will see min AM CAD as primary with the Skyhammer annihilation force and the rest lots of ambushing genestealer cult units?

    • Avatar
      Ytook October 8, 2016 6:23 am #

      Genestealer Cult are come the apocalypse allies with marines, which I think isn’t allowed in ITC I think?

  9. Avatar
    Novastar October 8, 2016 5:43 am #

    The book about Magnus is the 3rd book in the 18 book series where each one features a Primarch, book one was about Guiliman, 2 is on preorder now about Russ etc, they all take place before or during the Heresy

    • Reecius
      Reecius October 8, 2016 7:42 pm #

      Nice. Are they good reads?

  10. Avatar
    CaptainA October 8, 2016 7:21 am #

    Thanks for the shout out! We had 10 peeps show up for our first ITC league at A.B.U. Games! RTT this Nov 12th! Woot – https://www.facebook.com/events/1064228340352080/

  11. Avatar
    Will Grant October 9, 2016 6:02 am #

    For ITC, you can’t take IG and Nids with GSC in the same army correct?

    This would be bc IG and Nids are CTA allies.

    If we are going to allow this could we then go back and allow other bridge armies?

    THis would also mean that if you have a Chaos Space Marine force, you could have both Demon and Necron allies in the same army (with CSM bridging the gap).

    • Reecius
      Reecius October 9, 2016 10:16 am #

      That is exactly why we wouldn’t allow it, haha, as then we’re basically back to CTA.

      • Avatar
        Will Grant October 9, 2016 10:29 am #

        You may want to clarify this on the podcast.

        I think a lot of folks think GSC with both Nids/IG in same army is Rules as intended.

        • Reecius
          Reecius October 9, 2016 11:00 am #

          Clearly it is, CtA is allowed in the rules (but so is unbound, etc.). Most tournaments don’t allow CtA though as the majority of players do not enjoy having them.

  12. Avatar
    Jural October 10, 2016 9:01 am #

    I have spoken with 2 or 3 ITC vets who were confused on the concept of “bridge armies”, and asked for clarification here on a previous post.

    In the minds of many, your primary detachment determines which other formations are legal (I.e. the bridge concept.) It doesn’t really come up all that often, and indeed is worth a clarification.

    FWIW- I’d be OK with either ruling from a fluff, fun, competitive standpoint. Once we start allowing the Imperium to summon daemons, the whole CtA thing bothers me less and less 😉

Leave a Reply